Foundation
English
Verb
Tenses
Question

Fill in the blank with the most suitable option:
A: The attendant was smoking near the petrol pump.
B: He ______________ smoking there.

Wouldn't be
Shouldn't have been
Ought not to be
Shouldn't be
JEE Advance
College PredictorLive

Know your College Admission Chances Based on your Rank/Percentile, Category and Home State.

Get your JEE Main Personalised Report with Top Predicted Colleges in JoSA

Solution
Verified BY
Verified by Zigyan

This question tests your understanding of modal verbs and their correct usage in expressing prohibition or strong advice in past situations.

Step 1: Analyze the context
Sentence A describes a past event: "The attendant was smoking near the petrol pump." This action is dangerous and prohibited.

Step 2: Determine the required meaning for Sentence B
Sentence B needs to complete the idea: "He ______________ smoking there." This should express that the action was forbidden or highly inadvisable. Since the smoking already happened, we need a modal verb construction that refers to the past.

Step 3: Evaluate the options

  • Shouldn't have been: This is the correct "modal + perfect infinitive" structure (should+not+have+pastparticiple) used to criticize or express disapproval of a past action. It perfectly fits the context.
  • Wouldn't be: This expresses a future-in-the-past or a refusal, not a prohibition of a past action.
  • Shouldn't be: This is used for giving advice or stating prohibition about a present or general action, not a specific past event.
  • Ought not to be: Similar to "shouldn't be," this is used for present or general advice/prohibition, not for a past action.

Final Answer: The most suitable option is Shouldn't have been.

Sentence B becomes: "He shouldn't have been smoking there." This correctly states that his action of smoking in the past was wrong and prohibited.

Related Topic: Modal Verbs

Modal verbs (e.g., should, would, ought to, must, can) are auxiliary verbs used to express ability, possibility, permission, obligation, or advice. They are often followed by a base verb. To refer to the past, we frequently use the structure Modal + Have + Past Participle (e.g., should have gone, would have seen, must have been).

Key Formula/Structure

Expressing disapproval for a past action:
Subject+should/oughtto+not+have+pastparticiple

Example: You shouldn't have eaten so much cake. (Criticizing a past action)