Engineering
Physics
Conservation of Energy
SHM of Spring Block System
Collision
Question

A pan of mass 2 kg is resting in equilibrium on a spring of stiffness 200 N/m, as shown. A 0.5 kg lump of clay is released 5 m above the pan so that it hits the pan with some velocity and sticks to it. What will be the maximum downward descent of the pan from its initial position?


[Hint : Conserve momentum of clay + pan during collision and then apply energy equation. Do not neglect the initial compression of the spring]

JEE Advance
College PredictorLive

Know your College Admission Chances Based on your Rank/Percentile, Category and Home State.

Get your JEE Main Personalised Report with Top Predicted Colleges in JoSA

Solution
Verified BY
Verified by Zigyan

First, find the velocity of clay before impact using conservation of energy: 12mv2=mgh, so v=2gh=2×10×5=10 m/s downward.

During collision, momentum is conserved: mclayv=(mclay+mpan)vfinal, so 0.5×10=(2.5)vfinal, giving vfinal=2 m/s downward.

Initial spring compression: Fspring=kx0=mpang, so 200x0=2×10, x0=0.1 m.

Now apply energy conservation after collision. Let maximum descent be d from initial position. The change in spring potential energy is 12k(x0+d)2-12kx02, change in gravitational potential is -(mclay+mpan)gd, and initial kinetic energy is 12(mclay+mpan)vfinal2. Set total energy change to zero:

12k(x0+d)2-12kx02-(mclay+mpan)gd+12(mclay+mpan)vfinal2=0

Substitute values: 12×200×(0.1+d)2-12×200×0.12-2.5×10d+12×2.5×22=0

Simplify to 100(d+0.1)2-1-25d+5=0, then 100d2+20d+1-1-25d+5=0, so 100d2-5d+5=0.

Solve quadratic: d=5±25-2000200. Discard negative root, d=5+-1975200 not real? Correction: 100d2-5d+5=0 has discriminant 25-2000=-1975, error in sign. Actually, from earlier: 100d2+20d+1-1-25d+5=100d2-5d+5=0 is correct, but discriminant negative indicates math error. Re-check energy equation: initial compression energy is already stored, so term 12kx02 should not be subtracted? Actually, it is correct. The error is in constant: +1 -1 cancel, so 100d2-5d+5=0 gives d=5±25-2000200, but discriminant negative. The correct approach is to set the equation as 12k(x0+d)2=12kx02+(mclay+mpan)gd-12(mclay+mpan)vfinal2, but careful with signs. Actually, the energy conservation is: initial kinetic + initial spring potential + initial gravitational potential = final spring potential + final gravitational potential (with lowest point as reference). At initial position after collision, spring energy is 12kx02, gravitational potential is 0 (reference), kinetic is 12(2.5)22=5 J. At lowest point, spring energy is 12k(x0+d)2, gravitational potential is -(2.5)gd, kinetic is 0. So:

12kx02+5=12k(x0+d)2-25d

Substitute: 12×200×0.01+5=12×200×(d+0.1)2-25d

1+5=100(d+0.1)2-25d

6=100d2+20d+1-25d

6=100d2-5d+1

100d2-5d-5=0

Solve: d=5±25+2000200=5±2025200=5±45200

Take positive root: d=50200=0.25 m.

Final answer: 0.25 m