A pan of mass 2 kg is resting in equilibrium on a spring of stiffness 200 N/m, as shown. A 0.5 kg lump of clay is released 5 m above the pan so that it hits the pan with some velocity and sticks to it. What will be the maximum downward descent of the pan from its initial position?

[Hint : Conserve momentum of clay + pan during collision and then apply energy equation. Do not neglect the initial compression of the spring]
Know your College Admission Chances Based on your Rank/Percentile, Category and Home State.
Get your JEE Main Personalised Report with Top Predicted Colleges in JoSA
First, find the velocity of clay before impact using conservation of energy: , so downward.
During collision, momentum is conserved: , so , giving downward.
Initial spring compression: , so , .
Now apply energy conservation after collision. Let maximum descent be from initial position. The change in spring potential energy is , change in gravitational potential is , and initial kinetic energy is . Set total energy change to zero:
Substitute values:
Simplify to , then , so .
Solve quadratic: . Discard negative root, not real? Correction: has discriminant , error in sign. Actually, from earlier: is correct, but discriminant negative indicates math error. Re-check energy equation: initial compression energy is already stored, so term should not be subtracted? Actually, it is correct. The error is in constant: +1 -1 cancel, so gives , but discriminant negative. The correct approach is to set the equation as , but careful with signs. Actually, the energy conservation is: initial kinetic + initial spring potential + initial gravitational potential = final spring potential + final gravitational potential (with lowest point as reference). At initial position after collision, spring energy is , gravitational potential is 0 (reference), kinetic is . At lowest point, spring energy is , gravitational potential is , kinetic is 0. So:
Substitute:
Solve:
Take positive root: .
Final answer: 0.25 m